Do you remember when as a child you believed that god watched over you from the ceiling and monsters waited under your bed? When garden fairies enchanted the backyard and goblins lurked in the basement? These invisible beings “imaginated” your generalized intuition of Reality as imbued with conscious personality, agency, and intention.
It didn’t matter that you never encountered such phantasmagoria in the so-called real world, since that wasn’t where they were centered anyway.
They were magical forms conjured in your imagination as a more or less spontaneous reflex of your sense of living in a web of communion with all things. The vibrational sympathy in your body with everything going on around you welled up to the surface of your conscious awareness in these imaginary beings – watching over you, waiting for you, activating wonder and warning you away from dangerous places.
The god who looked down from your bedroom ceiling was not the construct of theological orthodoxy. Later on, if you happened to grow up in a household of religiously affiliated taller powers, this animistic notion of god would be incorporated into the orthodox-theistic doctrine of the deity worshipped in a tradition of true believers.
In the course of your faith development, that orthodox costume of god would gradually be slipped over the imaginated power from early childhood and come to life.
This forward shift in faith development corresponds to the progress of religious sensibility from animism to theism, from a body-centered and nature-based spirituality to one that is ego-centered and based in the society of your tribe – referring to the protected membership of a shared social identity. An important part of this shared identity is the deity, as a common focus of authority, inspiration, and worship.
Concerns of this stage in faith development are largely understood inside a moral frame that defines a “good person” and “right action.” The deity of theism plays the roles of law-giver, arbitrator of right and wrong, and final judge who metes out rewards and punishments not just at the end of life but all along the way.
The stories by this time have scaled-out from backyard garden fairytales to folk legends and epic myths centering the tribe in a creation history of god’s design.
To say that tribal life and its theistic orientation are ego-centered simply means that your lived experience is now firmly stationed in the moral frame and its focus on personal identity – your own, that of others, those who have departed (departure itself is a newer concept central in many theistic salvation stories), and of the deity upon whom Freud fashioned his notion of the superego.
To be ego-centered is simply to be conscious of yourself, recognized by others as belonging to a tribe of like-minded persons.
If you came up in a religiously affiliated household of taller powers, your background conditioning served to situate your identity in the moral frame of your tribe, instilled with the desire to be good and belong (notice the halo above your ego in my diagram).
A closely guarded secret among the tribal leadership acknowledges its god as a metaphor and not a being at large in the real world. Some have forgotten, it is true, or were never let in on the secret to begin with. (At a time of biblical literalism, many seminary graduates today are reinforced in the belief that god is out there, up there – somewhere.) The great disservice to theism and faith development lies in their dogmatic insistence on god’s objective existence.
Under their oppressive influence, tribal members come to adopt the same unfounded (and experientially disassociated) belief. Thanks to them, your own intuition of god as an imaginated form representing the deeper communion and intention of Reality likely died inside the orthodox costume of your tribe’s patron deity.
To understand (a lowercase) god as a mythopoetic metaphor of (the uppercase) God – as an imaginated form of the present Mystery – is the insight that carries faith development across the distinct frames of religion: from animism, through theism, and into a post-theistic spirituality.
Sadly, however, many (many) theistic true believers today are stuck in the moral frame, closed off to the Mystery and clutching their idols in an unsettled state of doubt and fear, overcompensating with an aggressive conviction and ambitious plans to convert the rest of the world to their “truth.”
Something inside them knows they are clutching a counterfeit, but what else can they do?
You may be one of the millions who have elected to save faith by leaving their religion. As our current era moves more fully into a socially diverse, morally pluralistic, and globally connected way of life, the squeezing pressure of a moral frame that will not accommodate such a diversity of views, values, and lifestyles soon becomes intolerable.
The choice becomes either one of a fundamentalist regression to a set of practically irrelevant convictions, as in contemporary Evangelical Christianity and radical Islamism, or a courageous (if somewhat desperate) exodus from moral and intellectual bondage to spiritual freedom.
The frame of religion that awaits the refugee from dogmatic theism is named ‘post-theism’ for its conscious and communal cultivation of faith “after god” – that is to say, after taking leave of the lowercase god and its protected membership of true believers.
Of course, this advancing shift from theism to post-theism can be fairly trouble-free – as it naturally would be if theism could honor and contemplate its god as a (and not the only) mythopoetic metaphor of the present Mystery of Reality (i.e., the uppercase God) and help its members through the moral frame to a more liberated life.
A post-theistic faith and spirituality is properly identified as mystical for its acknowledgement of the present Mystery as beyond name and form.
You are invited from an ego-centered to a soul-centered experience.
The present Mystery’s ineffability is such that no conceptual labels can stick to it and no doctrinal boxes can contain it. True to the term “mystery,” its experience has the effect of evoking wonder, astonishment, tranquility, and awed silence (muein = to close the mouth) – all at once.
Post-theistic faith and spirituality is not merely an “inner” experience, however. With an awareness – very likely a dim memory from your early childhood with the backyard garden fairies – of the deeper oneness in all things, the liberated mind is drawn farther out and upward into a higher wholeness where All is One and We’re All in This Together (two universal principles of spiritual wisdom).
Moral values of tribal life break open to the ethical ideals of genuine community. In some cases, a guilty conscience is intentionally transcended for “conscientious guilt,” when you know deepest down that welcoming the stranger and loving your enemy are truly the right thing to do, even though it violates the morality of your tribe and puts you at risk of getting kicked out of the club.









